How obvious is a ‘manifest error’?

Crawford Jamieson

In Amey Birmingham Highways v Birmingham City Council, the Court of Appeal offered guidance on the meaning of the phrase ‘manifest error’. Under a PFI contract with the City Council, Amey agreed to maintain Birmingham’s road system. The roads to be maintained were defined by reference to a data set, 60% of which was based Read More

No Comments

701 Aggregations. Spotting when many insurance claims are treated as a single pack

Russell Butland

In Spire v Royal & Sun Alliance the Court of Appeal held that over 700 claims of the victims of surgeon Ian Paterson should be aggregated as a single claim for the purposes of the hospital’s liability policy. Spire runs a number of private hospitals where Ian Paterson, a Consultant Breast Surgeon, operated. Over 700 Read More

No Comments

Certainty prevails: cause of action accrues when work done

Megan Betts

In Ice Architects v Empowering People Inspiring Communities, the High Court held that the entitlement to payment for work by ICE arose when the work was done, not when the invoice expired. ICE provided design services to EPIC. The agreement stated that the “basis of payment” was that ICE “will invoice EPIC on a monthly basis Read More

No Comments

Devil’s in the detail: is your notice of breach good enough?

Megan Betts

In Teoco  v Aircom, the Court of Appeal found that letters sent by the purchaser, Teoco, to the sellers, Aircom, under a share purchase agreement did not constitute valid notice of intention to bring a claim for breach of warranty and accordingly the claim had been correctly struck out. The relevant provision specified that the Read More

No Comments

A (conditional) free for all?

Lucy Judge

Budana v Leeds Hospital is about Conditional Fee Agreements and how they may be transferred. Ms Budana’s original solicitors, Baker Rees, represented her in a personal injury claim under a CFA with a 100% success fee, entered into under the pre-Jackson reform regime. Baker Rees purported to assign its book of personal injury claims, and CFAs, Read More

No Comments

No chinks in the chain of causation: liability for continuing loss and third party acts

Samantha Holland

Questions of causation are tricky for lawyers and highly fact dependent. This case is an example of how it can be difficult to change a tribunal’s finding on causation: St Shipping v Space Shipping. A charterer hired a vessel and sub-hired it on to a third party that intended, unlawfully, to export crude oil from Read More

No Comments

Retro scooters: a licence to ride?

Adrian Dykes

In Scomadi v RA Engineering, the High Court construed a poorly drafted agreement against a licensor, meaning that the licensee could continue to manufacture the licensor’s retro scooter, even after the original agreement was terminated. Scomadi entered an agreement with Hanwei for the design and manufacture of a retro scooter. The agreement provided that Scomadi Read More

No Comments

Breaking the chain: when breach is not the cause of loss

Michaela Widdowson-Kidd

By designing a hotel for twice the budget, Fosters breached the contract. But, this was not the reason the developer could not secure funding for the project and therefore Fosters was not liable for the developer’s lost profits: Riva v Foster + Partners. The developer engaged Fosters to design a hotel for £70 million pounds; Read More

No Comments

What’s the ETA?

Katie Sharkey

The High Court has established that an estimated time of arrival can be implied into a shipping contract where the ETAs of unrelated intermediate voyages are provided, even if an ETA for the voyage in question is not stipulated. Previous authority had held that where a charterparty gives an ETA (or a date which can Read More

No Comments

Rainer Evers

Jason Rix

Yesterday I learnt that Rainer Evers, one of the team of three behind this blog, died over the weekend. It’s incredibly difficult to know what to say, not least because I can hear him tearing me apart mid-sentence for my grammatical errors and lack of clarity. Here is an example of a typical email exchange. Read More

One comment