Frustration / force majeure

Force Majeure and Causation: iron-ing out the issues

Laurence Ridgway

In Classic Maritime v Limbunga, the High Court held that a contractual force majeure clause incorporated a “but for” test of causation. Limbunga, a charterer, contracted to provide iron ore for shipment by Classic Maritime, a ship owner. Limbunga failed to do so after a burst dam forced the mine that supplied the iron ore Read More

No Comments

Project Voldemort and the Riddle of force majeure

Benjamin Scrace

In Seadrill Ghana Operations v Tullow Ghana, the High Court found that a defaulting party cannot rely upon “force majeure” to terminate a contract if only one of two events preventing performance is a force majeure event. Oil company Tullow hired a semi-submersible drilling rig from Seadrill for operations off the Ghanaian coast, including in Read More

No Comments

Civil unrest, frustrated performances and a thrilling decision – you just cannot beat it

Sherin Bhasker

In The Flying Music Company v Theatre Entertainment, the High Court considered whether a contract to put on “Thriller Live” in Greece had been frustrated by civil unrest. It also covered whether a personal guarantee was supported by consideration and/or voidable for duress. A counterclaim for unjust enrichment and quantum issues were also considered. In Read More

No Comments

Troubled times: force majeure

Jason Rix

Why do we need force majeure clauses? The answer is that the common law doctrine of frustration is narrow and the consequences are blunt: the contract is “killed” with no power of suspension. The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 allows statutory adjustment but it is short, complex and difficult to navigate. Freedom of contract Read More

No Comments

Frustration: no one’s answering my call!

Damien Ryan

If a contract has been frustrated both parties are discharged from their future obligations and the subject matter of the contract may be destroyed (Taylor v Caldwell). Unsurprisingly, therefore, the threshold to establish frustration is high. Frustration depends on a so-called “supervening event” occurring which renders future performance radically different from what the parties had Read More

No Comments